Just like Dustin Kirkland, I too read planet.ubuntu.com every day. Well, almost every day. And just like Dustin, I too read Aaron Toponce's blog posts regularly.
I was flabbergasted by today's post Server Migration From Ubuntu 8.04 To Debian 5.0
Aaron writes:
For example, when I wanted to host my web site on it, I needed to know how to make that happen. I found a HOWTO on howtoforge for installing Apache, as well as ISPConfig, and a number of other packages that I realise now were not necessary. In fact, I ended up removing ISPConnfig a couple years later, as it was causing problems with logs, consuming a large amount of RAM, and just getting in the way.
Well, I have run this setup for a while professionally, and never got a problem with it's stability, nor it's logs, nor it's RAM consumption.
Then I wanted to run my own email server. Not knowing how to set an email server up, I fiddled with Exim, Sendmail, Postfix and others, failing at every pass, and further causing havoc on the filesystem and DPKG database. Eventually, I found the help I needed from a friend, and was able to get a Postfix server up and running as an external MTA. There were many other services I messed with from time to time, testing this out or the other, slowly filling the filesystem with pointless stuff. In a nutshell, what I’m trying to say, is the Ubuntu 8.04 install, while functional, was no longer pretty. It was hackish at best.
What do you mean not knowing how to set up a mail server? I, for one, am certainly not an expert in this matter, but I've managed to set up postfix in about one hour, following an excellent howto, which I think was provided by howtforge.
Now, with that said, I personally have never had any problems with my LTS server, either Dapper 6.06 or Hardy 8.04. But do I want to risk it? Should I chance it? While nothing may ever happen that causes critical concern for me with an LTS release, I feel more comfortable putting my trust in Debian stable than I do Ubuntu LTS.
Ehr? Excuse me? Let me rephrase that: "Now, with that said, I personally never had any problems with my knowledge. But do I want to risk it? Should I chance with it? While nothing may ever happen that causes concern for me with my knowledge, I feel more comfortable putting my trust in faith than I do in knowledge". Sounds insane? Well, maybe it does, but then again, if you never had problems with Ubuntu LTS, how can you feel more comfortable in running Debian stable, which is just upgraded, and thus hasn't proven it's stability yet?
The entire post sounds like an attempt to spread FUD to me, and imho doesn't belong on planet.ubuntu.com.